beefystud

is air blowing out of the oil fill hole while the car is running normal ? some people say its fine while others say its not , all three of my hondas (s2000,cx,vx) have air coming out the oil fill hole , one of my mechanics evan said i probably need a rebuild on my 1992 honda civic vx because of this ,

is this something i need to fix ? i did a leak down test and a compression test and lab scoped my crank and cams and every things is fine (s2000) ,i checked my friends 2016 corrolla and he has the same thing , how can air coming out of the oil hole be a sign of blow by when it seems all cars have it ?

i would also like to ad that my mechanic says the blow by is the cause of my oil leak on my brand new oil pan for the civic vx , is my mechanic just making excuses cause he cant seal my oil pan properly ? or is it really blow by causing my oil pan not to seal? the vx also has surging while coasting at high speeds in neutral

zeroptzero

don't sweat it, every modern car has that phenomena. Some of it is blow-by, and every car has blow-by, hence the pcv system on all modern cars. Also the pistons rushing downwards create positive pressure in the crankcase which vents to the valvecover, opening the oil cap with the engine running allows the pressurized air to escape. Don't listen to dumb people. Rule #1.

beefystud

so what of the oil pan ? the civic vx is 27 years old and has 120,000 miles on it , could he be right about blow by causing my oil pan not to seal ? or is he just making excuses cause he doesnt want to sen back the oil pan and give me any more free labor ? is the surging while coasting in neutral a sign of blow by? why would he take the oil cap off the engine while its running and say " look theres air coming out your hole, theres blow by" when all cars do this ? doesnt he know i post on s2ki.com ?

zeroptzero

A newly sealed oil pan won't leak due to blow-by as there is always relief for the excess pressure on the top end, the oil pan leaks because it was not installed properly or with inferior materials and practices. Make sure your pcv system and pcv valve is working properly as that is where blow-by gets relieved. I recall some older Hondas used a collection tank which opened to the lower block, which then branched off to the upper head, make sure that system is all in tact and working properly and not plugged if it exists on you Civic. Surging of the motor is not a sign of blow-by, it could be many items causing that including a vacuum leak. You could have a vacuum leak on the pcv system or throttle body , etc.

beefystud

he replaced both pcv valves and said the problem still isant fixed , he also mentioened the collection tank just as you have , he then told me my engine was tired and the blow by was causeing the leak do to bad collection tank , what should i say to him when i take it back on monday ?

jetboater

freq

x2

rpg51

I don't dump on a mechanic until I hear his/her side of the story. Its possible that the content and meaning of a mechanic's communications might be lost in the translation.

beefystud

i would also like to ad that i tried fixing the oil pan my self 3 times and it leaked on me all three times, i used a spectre oil pan i bought from o reilly auto, after failing i gave him the car , he first told me it was a bad oil pan that did not have flat edges , so they got me a new one from napa ( which was all so a spectre) the first time he installed it leaked , he took another shot at it and used silicone the second time and it still leaked

beefystud

hes saying the oil pan wont seal because of positive crank case presser which he thinks is a result of a tired engine