Help! Random power loss in 1st gear
#1
Registered User
Thread Starter
Join Date: Apr 2006
Location: Sutton Coldfield
Posts: 525
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Help! Random power loss in 1st gear
Hi all,
This isn't the usual 'power loss/jerky map whack' problem, it's a complete mystery and I've been trying to solve it for 8+ months.
The problem: It's completely sporadic, but this is what happens:
Drive car for 10 mins +, park up, engine off.. come back to car after 5-10 mins, engine fires up OK, pull away normally in first gear and BAM.. power loss/fuel cut.. car lurches and will not give any more power. Have to dip the clutch fast.. car idles, but doesn't die.
Turn engine off, back on again and it will either a) do it again or b) be absolutely fine for the rest of a short or long journey.
A few times it did it I was in a car park, so parked up and let the engine idle, it started to idling very rough. The issue doesn't happen 'mid motoring'.. it is always after a short drive, engine off, leave 5 mins, engine back on situation.
There are no engine codes/CELs.
I've had 3 garages try to find the fault, including a very competent guy I know and trust 100%, even he can't figure it out. Honda were no help whatsoever.
So far, I've had new MAP, TPS, Crank Sensor. Fuel pump was checked too, as was the CAT.
It's absolutely frustrating, my 'good mechanic' managed to replicate the problem, but his scanning equipment didn't show any codes, he is baffled too - said the car is un-drivable when it happens - I know!!
Like I say, it's random, and might not do it for weeks, and the car purrs like a cat.
I can't live with it much longer, please help.
This isn't the usual 'power loss/jerky map whack' problem, it's a complete mystery and I've been trying to solve it for 8+ months.
The problem: It's completely sporadic, but this is what happens:
Drive car for 10 mins +, park up, engine off.. come back to car after 5-10 mins, engine fires up OK, pull away normally in first gear and BAM.. power loss/fuel cut.. car lurches and will not give any more power. Have to dip the clutch fast.. car idles, but doesn't die.
Turn engine off, back on again and it will either a) do it again or b) be absolutely fine for the rest of a short or long journey.
A few times it did it I was in a car park, so parked up and let the engine idle, it started to idling very rough. The issue doesn't happen 'mid motoring'.. it is always after a short drive, engine off, leave 5 mins, engine back on situation.
There are no engine codes/CELs.
I've had 3 garages try to find the fault, including a very competent guy I know and trust 100%, even he can't figure it out. Honda were no help whatsoever.
So far, I've had new MAP, TPS, Crank Sensor. Fuel pump was checked too, as was the CAT.
It's absolutely frustrating, my 'good mechanic' managed to replicate the problem, but his scanning equipment didn't show any codes, he is baffled too - said the car is un-drivable when it happens - I know!!
Like I say, it's random, and might not do it for weeks, and the car purrs like a cat.
I can't live with it much longer, please help.
#2
Main fuel relay can be a problem on some Honda,the problem a dry joint so an intermittent fault.
speed sensor
speed sensor
#3
Member
Im having the same issue on mine but not had time to look at it yet. Its not ideal when it happens on the formation lap!!
It feels like it's fuel related to me, although changing injectors and coils didnt cure it. The fuel relay is worth a look, as is your earthing.
It will be something simple, but not easy to find!
It feels like it's fuel related to me, although changing injectors and coils didnt cure it. The fuel relay is worth a look, as is your earthing.
It will be something simple, but not easy to find!
#4
Well looking at the combustion triangle it's unlikely to be a compression issue, which means mixture induction or ignition.
Is the car drive by wire throttle or cable?
Ignition components in good condition? Wiring to coilpacks, the coilpacks themselves (remove and shake, listen for rattles), any seal damage?
What about the plugs?
Apart from that it does sound fuel/throttle related.
The relay is a good shout, as would be pump wiring. Have you tried battery off for 10 mins? (Sorry it you have and I'd missed it)
Is the car drive by wire throttle or cable?
Ignition components in good condition? Wiring to coilpacks, the coilpacks themselves (remove and shake, listen for rattles), any seal damage?
What about the plugs?
Apart from that it does sound fuel/throttle related.
The relay is a good shout, as would be pump wiring. Have you tried battery off for 10 mins? (Sorry it you have and I'd missed it)
#5
Registered User
Join Date: Sep 2002
Location: hampshire
Posts: 2,026
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
faulty coolant temp sensor? they normaly start to 'go' as your describing....
the coolants getting to a resonable temp, car is turned off... car 'warm' started and the ECU doesnt like the reading from the temp sensor so it dumps too much fuel in causing the boggyness.
has happened on 2 hondas I have had and its a cheap part to try before you venture in to injectors etc
the coolants getting to a resonable temp, car is turned off... car 'warm' started and the ECU doesnt like the reading from the temp sensor so it dumps too much fuel in causing the boggyness.
has happened on 2 hondas I have had and its a cheap part to try before you venture in to injectors etc
#7
Registered User
Thread Starter
Join Date: Apr 2006
Location: Sutton Coldfield
Posts: 525
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
faulty coolant temp sensor? they normaly start to 'go' as your describing....
the coolants getting to a resonable temp, car is turned off... car 'warm' started and the ECU doesnt like the reading from the temp sensor so it dumps too much fuel in causing the boggyness.
has happened on 2 hondas I have had and its a cheap part to try before you venture in to injectors etc
the coolants getting to a resonable temp, car is turned off... car 'warm' started and the ECU doesnt like the reading from the temp sensor so it dumps too much fuel in causing the boggyness.
has happened on 2 hondas I have had and its a cheap part to try before you venture in to injectors etc
Thing is, my issue isn't bogginess, it's more 'instant', like fuel shut down. I can rev the engine with the clutch dipped, but when I pull away in gear it happens.
If a coolant sensor, would a CEL not flag up?
Trending Topics
#9
Does it die at >3000rpm or does it happen before that?
I'm wondering if you've got a cam sensor loose at the back of the block.
I'm wondering if you've got a cam sensor loose at the back of the block.
#10
Registered User
Thread Starter
Join Date: Apr 2006
Location: Sutton Coldfield
Posts: 525
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
But.. if the car starts and runs OK, and the problem doesn't present itself, it will happily drive perfectly.
If it were something loose, I'd presume that the problem wouldn't happen under such specific circumstances?