Cookie Competition
Thread Starter
Joined: Apr 2003
Posts: 770
Likes: 1
From: Rehoboth, MA
Cookie Competition
OK folks. Here's the thinking on how we might do this ...
Eligibility Requirements:
* must be a cookie .. anything you have to cut like cakes, pie, fudge, souffles, bake alaska etc. is not eligible
* must be able to eat it and hold it with your fingers ... with out it falling apart or making a god awful mess
* must have some form of flour and sugar in it (if not, it ain't a cookie, it's a fruit roll-up)
* May be either home made or store bought
Judging Criteria:
* Taste (75 pts)
* Appearance (20 pts)
* Unique, Yet Relevant Name (5 pts)
Each item rated on a 3 point scale:
1 = "Interesting But Not To My Taste" / Run of the Mill / WTF-Must Be An Inside Joke
2 = "Pls. Sir May I Have Another" / Very Nice Effort / Name Says It All
3 = "I Want The Recipe" / Ben-Get Your Camera / Funny-You Must Be A Marketeer
WINNER = highest weighted average score from all submitted entries.
PRIZE = Bottle of Irish Cream or Fine Red Wine (winners choice)
Other suggestions? Let me hear 'em.
Eligibility Requirements:
* must be a cookie .. anything you have to cut like cakes, pie, fudge, souffles, bake alaska etc. is not eligible
* must be able to eat it and hold it with your fingers ... with out it falling apart or making a god awful mess
* must have some form of flour and sugar in it (if not, it ain't a cookie, it's a fruit roll-up)
* May be either home made or store bought
Judging Criteria:
* Taste (75 pts)
* Appearance (20 pts)
* Unique, Yet Relevant Name (5 pts)
Each item rated on a 3 point scale:
1 = "Interesting But Not To My Taste" / Run of the Mill / WTF-Must Be An Inside Joke
2 = "Pls. Sir May I Have Another" / Very Nice Effort / Name Says It All
3 = "I Want The Recipe" / Ben-Get Your Camera / Funny-You Must Be A Marketeer
WINNER = highest weighted average score from all submitted entries.
PRIZE = Bottle of Irish Cream or Fine Red Wine (winners choice)
Other suggestions? Let me hear 'em.
Joined: Feb 2004
Posts: 65,338
Likes: 4,647
From: Smalltown
Originally Posted by djweaver,Jan 17 2007, 12:03 AM
Lainey,
Bean is throwing her hat in the ring and baking on Friday. Betty better be fresh and sassy
Bean is throwing her hat in the ring and baking on Friday. Betty better be fresh and sassy
I've had Potato salad by Beanie.......I think we now have a contest!
Registered User
Joined: Jul 2002
Posts: 15,719
Likes: 0
From: Westport, MA
Fair warning to all, I have found a recipe that will dominate the cookie competition. I am not going to reveal anything about my special cookies, however it will be worth the suspense. I will be the new Betty Crocker around here.... Wait, thats not cool... Well, my cookies will be good darn it! Baking a test run this afternoon.
Trending Topics
Registered User
Joined: Aug 2005
Posts: 3,247
Likes: 0
From: Fairhaven MA
Originally Posted by sireousrex,Jan 17 2007, 06:23 AM
Fair warning to all, I have found a recipe that will dominate the cookie competition. I am not going to reveal anything about my special cookies, however it will be worth the suspense. I will be the new Betty Crocker around here.... Wait, thats not cool... Well, my cookies will be good darn it! Baking a test run this afternoon.
Joined: Feb 2004
Posts: 65,338
Likes: 4,647
From: Smalltown
Originally Posted by sireousrex,Jan 17 2007, 09:23 AM
Fair warning to all, I have found a recipe that will dominate the cookie competition. I am not going to reveal anything about my special cookies, however it will be worth the suspense. I will be the new Betty Crocker around here.... Wait, thats not cool... Well, my cookies will be good darn it! Baking a test run this afternoon.
Rick has been pushing me to stop all the baking and start brewing beer instead.
