Grammar Police...
I'm no grammer expert but if the second term were to be used in a properly constructed sentence it would be the correct use of the word 'belated' IMO.
The first implies that the person's actual birthday was belated (an impossibility) instead of the greetings.
The first implies that the person's actual birthday was belated (an impossibility) instead of the greetings.
Originally Posted by Muz,Apr 25 2006, 01:55 PM
I'm no grammer expert but if the second term were to be used in a properly constructed sentence it would be the correct use of the word 'belated' IMO.
The first implies that the person's actual birthday was belated (an impossibility) instead of the greetings.
The first implies that the person's actual birthday was belated (an impossibility) instead of the greetings.
The first makes no sense to me, though it is what people always use.
Originally Posted by Muz,Apr 25 2006, 03:55 PM
I'm no grammer expert but if the second term were to be used in a properly constructed sentence it would be the correct use of the word 'belated' IMO.
The first implies that the person's actual birthday was belated (an impossibility) instead of the greetings.
The first implies that the person's actual birthday was belated (an impossibility) instead of the greetings.
Trending Topics
Originally Posted by gosixers215,Apr 25 2006, 02:55 PM
Muz makes a good point, but "happy belated birthday" is the most commonly used form of the phrase, so I would go with that one.
I'll argue for the second. As Muz pointed out, the birthday is not belated, just the wishes.
Where are all the English teachers...? Weigh in already!
Originally Posted by gosixers215,Apr 25 2006, 02:55 PM
Muz makes a good point, but "happy belated birthday" is the most commonly used form of the phrase, so I would go with that one.
Oh, and "Belated happy birthday" is correct grammatically; "Happy belated birthday" is not.
I've never heard anyone say "Happy belated birthday" before. "A belated happy birthday" is the only version I've ever seen or heard, and as magician pointed out, it's the only grammatically correct version.



