I've noticed in my 09' that the passenger seat doesn't recline as far as the driver seat. My old 05' I didn't have this issue. Any help would be appreciated. Drives me crazy that I can't get it to match the driver side.

 

Funny you mentioned that. I have noticed my 09 seat top was never exactly like each other, I assumed it was the way my wife liked hers. I just thought I would have to play with it to get them identical but never have really tried. Now I may have to give it a go sometime. No change after removing and reinstalling seats for NVH floor insulation.

 

Ha!!! I had an '05. I was rear-ended, it got totalled and I have an '09 now too. I'm kind of tall. Neither seat reclines as far back as the '05 seats would. This is one of the first differences I noticed. I loved my '05.