I won't speak to the quality of competitors wheels, but I will say that if cost is a concern, we're still offering a pre-order discount for our Flow Formed VS-5 where you could pick up a set of the 17x9.5" ET51 for right around $1,400 shipped! Just something to keep in mind.

 

This is the deal to get.

Also, since OP is intending this for track use, it's good to note that APEX has a 50% off wheel replacement program. Track wheels get beat up, bent, and cracked all the time, not an if, but a when.

https://apexwheels.com/replacement-p...BoC6VgQAvD_BwE

 

This is really helpful. Ok... So, I don't want to roll the fenders or make body modification. Also, I appreciate the advice about good pads vs. a BBK, so I'll plan to avoid the BBK. With that, could I get some recommendations on a good set of wheels that won't break the bank and keep the stock staggered sizes? Thanks!

 

IF you don't want to roll and want stock staggered sizes, then a second set of OEM wheels... search ebay.

https://www.ebay.com/itm/20487644864...gaAnugEALw_wcB

or there's a set posted in the forums too.

https://www.s2ki.com/forums/market/1221417

You could actually also get the apex 17x9 +61 wheels and mount 225/255 staggered tires on them. It will be at the limit of functionally stretched up front, which will help with responsiveness and feel, which is beneficial up to a point. ASMotorsport stretches a 255 on a 10.5 wide wheel, so this is within a similar amount of stretch.