I am going nuts!!! I'm bringing my Wrangler back from overseas in July and now I'm in a corner again. I kinda ditched the idea of getting an S when I sell my 330ci since my other car is a mustang and neither would be too good in the winter so I had settled on buying a buddy of mine's 95 M3... but now that I'm going to have the Wrangler to zipp around in.. the option for the S has opened up again.

Standing at 6'6" I know i can make it work (posted other threads about my ideas and options) but the M3 would offer more room out of the box.

In terms of Performance, the S is the hands down winner in my book (as far as what i'm looking for).

My only hesitation is that it may not be as practical as the M3...

I need some kind of closure that it wont be a mistake to buy this thing... HELP!

 

ok i'll be the first to help you out here, I test drove an M3, and i can honestly say that with the exception of the tiny back seat (good enough for an 8 year old) the M3 is not more practical than the S2K. If its a fitment issue i understand that, you are tall, but if you say you can fit than go for it.

You may be able to get a used S2k for the same price thats in warranty
It will be a much newer car
Honda Reliability
Lower Mileage
Top Down Driving
A much rarer car than a 95 M3
And need i remind you of those rising gas prices!
Lastly, this unbelievable community of owners and enthusiasts!