The Limits of Civil Discussion on S2KI
Thread Starter
Joined: Oct 2000
Posts: 18,885
Likes: 33
From: Philly (Narberth)
The Limits of Civil Discussion on S2KI
Interesting....wonder how this S2KI rule relates to Vintage topics?
I don't expect much discussion on this topic b/c people will be too timid to voice an opinion. Surprise me!
Rules
1. S2KI, its Administrators, Moderators and authorized agents, may remove, edit or move any content and/or delete, suspend or permanently bar any account at any time for any reason (or none at all) without notice or explanation.
2. You may not post any content or post links to any content which:
a) is hateful or incites hate against any person or group;
b) threatens harm toward any person, property or group;
c) depicts acts of violence, sexual exploitation or animal cruelty;
.......
1. S2KI, its Administrators, Moderators and authorized agents, may remove, edit or move any content and/or delete, suspend or permanently bar any account at any time for any reason (or none at all) without notice or explanation.
2. You may not post any content or post links to any content which:
a) is hateful or incites hate against any person or group;
b) threatens harm toward any person, property or group;
c) depicts acts of violence, sexual exploitation or animal cruelty;
.......
Joined: Nov 2002
Posts: 45,093
Likes: 4,016
From: Arlington, VA
I'm not too timid, which I'm sure you already know. 
Not sure why you posted this, but in the past Vintage COs/Admins have enforced the rules when necessary. Recently, I haven't seen any reason to, but I certainly would bring something up to Jim (S1997) or S2Ki Admins if necessary.
Not sure why you posted this, but in the past Vintage COs/Admins have enforced the rules when necessary. Recently, I haven't seen any reason to, but I certainly would bring something up to Jim (S1997) or S2Ki Admins if necessary.
Registered User
Joined: Aug 2009
Posts: 5,663
Likes: 235
From: West Los Angeles, CA
I'm not sure I understand the question. How that excerpt of the rules relates to Vintage is that they apply. Vintage, being a part of the S2ki website and forum, the S2ki rules apply.
I'm not sure how much discussion that requires or what opinions or timidness have to do with it. Is there something more to the question than I'm seeing?
I'm not sure how much discussion that requires or what opinions or timidness have to do with it. Is there something more to the question than I'm seeing?
Joined: Jan 2003
Posts: 10,868
Likes: 1,058
I think it works great. Once it get uncivil it's removed or sent to politics. The political forum is a great trash bag.
If there's a problem it's once in awhile people try to create an issue from a civil conversation to promote whatever position they want to push. Sometimes they'll create or pollute an existing thread for that purpose. Everyone recognizes it for what it is.
I assume they do that because they're bored and I don't begrudge them their boredom. I figure they're trying to reach out and stimulate conversation.
Works for me, I already know everything there is to know about an S2000.
fltsfshr
If there's a problem it's once in awhile people try to create an issue from a civil conversation to promote whatever position they want to push. Sometimes they'll create or pollute an existing thread for that purpose. Everyone recognizes it for what it is.
I assume they do that because they're bored and I don't begrudge them their boredom. I figure they're trying to reach out and stimulate conversation.Works for me, I already know everything there is to know about an S2000.
fltsfshr
Thread Starter
Joined: Oct 2000
Posts: 18,885
Likes: 33
From: Philly (Narberth)
Originally Posted by paS2K' timestamp='1362927438' post='22393181
Interesting....wonder how this S2KI rule relates to Vintage topics?
I'm not sure how much discussion that requires or what opinions or timidness have to do with it. Is there something more to the question than I'm seeing?
Registered User
Joined: Aug 2009
Posts: 5,663
Likes: 235
From: West Los Angeles, CA
Trending Topics
Former Moderator
Joined: Oct 2003
Posts: 17,122
Likes: 629
From: Houston/Durango
I don't totally agree. The Politics Subforum is not intended to be a remedy for uncivil posting conduct. The rules apply there as well. The Politics Subforum is there for members who enjoy civil political discussions.
Thread Starter
Joined: Oct 2000
Posts: 18,885
Likes: 33
From: Philly (Narberth)
Just to get some further clarification, Jim:
If I start a thread entitled "Means of Capital Punishment" and add the subtitle "Not a Political Thead", it's OK for people to carry on discussions in the main forum about disembowelment, protocol of a firing squad, the effect of the Rack, product specs of drugs that can extinguish life and the length of time it takes, types of handcuffs and other restraints that can be used to secure the guilty party, effects on the body after hanging as a means of execution, etc. Posting pictures of products would also be ok....just like a new set of rims or the view of your engine compartment with strut tower brace and blower.
Capital punishment is a law in most states, so comments on these topics would not relate to torture or bodily harm per se. As long as no one verges into what conservatives and liberals believe about capital punishment, then it would be ok....correct?
If I start a thread entitled "Means of Capital Punishment" and add the subtitle "Not a Political Thead", it's OK for people to carry on discussions in the main forum about disembowelment, protocol of a firing squad, the effect of the Rack, product specs of drugs that can extinguish life and the length of time it takes, types of handcuffs and other restraints that can be used to secure the guilty party, effects on the body after hanging as a means of execution, etc. Posting pictures of products would also be ok....just like a new set of rims or the view of your engine compartment with strut tower brace and blower.
Capital punishment is a law in most states, so comments on these topics would not relate to torture or bodily harm per se. As long as no one verges into what conservatives and liberals believe about capital punishment, then it would be ok....correct?