How do I turn on email notifications when someone replies to a thread I started or to a thread I replied to that someone else started?

 

Go to "MyS2K & Settings". On the left side under "General Options", look for "Email Settings" and then check the appropriate check boxes.

 

I have all the forum preferences checked and I still receive no email notifications for replies to my subscribed/started threads.

Thanks.

 

Works fine for me. Maybe there's going into your spam filter or to another email address altogether. If you click "Change Email Address", it'll show you to what email address your notifications are currently going.