I'd give her both.

 

Tiffany is not a great value if you are only talking about the stone, true. But there are other factors. I for one love the traditional Tiffany 6 point setting- others imitate it but the ones I have seen never look that good. The prongs of the Tiffany setting are perfectly shaped and very delicate looking, and they hold the diamond quite high- all of the Tiffany knockoff settings I have seen look kinda chunky in comparison.

And then there is the whole blue box thing- to some that is worth something. Really the only ones who can judge what is "worth it" are you and your fiancee-to-be.

Peter

 

Tiffany's is definitely overpriced but for some it's the difference between good and great. I spent Christmas Eve in their store last holiday season.

I have to agree with PoweredByCamry, it's up to you and your future wife.

 

nah.. princess cut was a trend... traditional is the way to go..


but honestly dude in my opinion.. if my man gave me his mom's ring.. that would mean more to me than all the Tiffany's rings in the world.. to me it is such an honor... go with ur mom's ring

 

Save the money for a downpayment on that house? Or if you already have a house, save that money for your kids college tuition.

Just a married man (6-years) speaking

My wife doesn't wear her ring - it was my mother's ring (went with tradition) but only the rock, not the setting

 

sorta like someone buying a boxster vs a miata, both are convertible, both have 2 seats, both get you to the same place (minus a lot of other things) but one costs a lot more.
its brand value i guess, like how bmw is worth more then say....toyota.
wats the retail on a 1 carat tiffany anyway?
saw some 2 carats in tiffany & co in Hong Kong, they were reasonably priced compared to the rock my lameass brother bought for his slutty money hungry ex.
she gave it back and my mother ended up taking it. hahahah. true story.

 

T,

Like I told you last night. Knowing Maria, I beleive she'll appreciate the ring your dad left a lot more than any ring you buy anywhere. I think the sentimental value of it alone is worth a lot more. Do what I suggested about blessing it, and just give it to her. Later down the line you can buy her another ring for your first anniversary or what not.

Good Luck! BTW Send me that pic later!
-Cin

 

I was pretty lucky. My grandma passed away a few years ago and my mom gave me her ring, it was a full 1 k, beautiful stone. I just took the stone and put it into a $1500 platnum setting.

We just got married last sunday

 

I'd ask her what she'd like, assuming she knows it's coming. I got a very good idea of what my wife would like by visiting various stores. She really liked a $45,000 ring at Hamilton Jewelers in Princeton, but we didn't buy that one
When she got it, she was thrilled. Exactly what she wanted.

 

I just wanted to say CONGRATZ!