MATH people I need some help in calculus!
Originally Posted by magician,Jul 11 2006, 07:58 AM
I wasn't suggesting that the answers were incorrect. I simply pointed out that the author misnamed the rule he sought to use.
I'm not sure who constitutes "we" in those who prefer to rewrite quotients as products and use the product rule instead of the quotient rule. I've been teaching calculus for over twenty years; neither I nor any other calculus instructor I know falls into that set.
I'm not sure who constitutes "we" in those who prefer to rewrite quotients as products and use the product rule instead of the quotient rule. I've been teaching calculus for over twenty years; neither I nor any other calculus instructor I know falls into that set.
Originally Posted by Rio S2K,Jul 11 2006, 08:40 AM
I wasn't suggesting that you were invalidating an otherwise correct answer so if I gave off that misconception then I apologize. The reason I thought most would prefer the product rule is because it doesn't directly incorporate a denominator term which tends to make a rational expression more complicated "looking". Don't get me wrong, the quotient rule should be mastered by any student taking a Calculus course but for post-course practices when both techniques have been mastered I personally prefer to interpret the quotient as a product so as apply the product rule rather than the quotient rule. Obviously, this little "trick" can not be done in every case but in situations where situable and time savings are available then I would take it.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post



