Boost Cooler?
I'm running about 4 degrees more timing across the board, and 10psi boost.
My MAX intake charge temp is 91F with the spray on. I've got a very small (meaning very fast response) thermocouple in the intake manifold. I've run with the spray off also - AFR is 12:1. I did feel the ECU pull timing on a hot day with the spray off - just like its suppose to. AFR is 10:7.1 with the spray on. Getting ready to pull the Shurflo pump and put in an Ulka 200 psi ($62).
Lots of sources mention that each 1 degree of charge cooling equates to 1% power increase possible, assuming you tune for it. Banks (of BanksPower) claims the number is more like 1.8% power per 1 degree charge cooling. Of course there are practical limits to it. Anyways a good WI system with failsafes seems like a good bang for the buck. IMO its actually safer than not having it - assuming you don't get ignant with the tune and boost level.
My MAX intake charge temp is 91F with the spray on. I've got a very small (meaning very fast response) thermocouple in the intake manifold. I've run with the spray off also - AFR is 12:1. I did feel the ECU pull timing on a hot day with the spray off - just like its suppose to. AFR is 10:7.1 with the spray on. Getting ready to pull the Shurflo pump and put in an Ulka 200 psi ($62).
Lots of sources mention that each 1 degree of charge cooling equates to 1% power increase possible, assuming you tune for it. Banks (of BanksPower) claims the number is more like 1.8% power per 1 degree charge cooling. Of course there are practical limits to it. Anyways a good WI system with failsafes seems like a good bang for the buck. IMO its actually safer than not having it - assuming you don't get ignant with the tune and boost level.
My main question would be if there are fail-safe measures to prevent detonation if the unit fails, are the adjustments (pulling timing, etc.) based on intake temp readings, or the output of the meth unit (unit sends signal to EMS, telling it that it is on and functioning)? If it does it based on whether the unit is "on" or "off" as opposed to threshold parameters on a result (intake temp) of the operation of the unit, it still may screw the engine if the controller unit still functions, but fails for some other reason (out of meth, leak, clogged sprayer, etc.).
I am not sure how the fail-safe's work. As long as the car is tuned to run without it, it should be fine, but then you are talking about not tuning for that 1.8% you could possibly gain by the cooler charge temp...
S2Kart - How did your AFR go down with the meth working? I would think it would be the opposite (cooler air, plus water = more oxygen. More oxygen + same injector duty cycle + more timing = more lean mixture). I know it is injecting some methanol, but I did not think it was that much when compared to the water component (% wise) of the mixture. Assuming your ECU is pulling timing when the meth is not running, that would result in less fuel being burned, and a more rich mixture being pulled out the exhaust... This is just thinking about theory.... I have very little experience with meth injection, personally...
John
I am not sure how the fail-safe's work. As long as the car is tuned to run without it, it should be fine, but then you are talking about not tuning for that 1.8% you could possibly gain by the cooler charge temp...
S2Kart - How did your AFR go down with the meth working? I would think it would be the opposite (cooler air, plus water = more oxygen. More oxygen + same injector duty cycle + more timing = more lean mixture). I know it is injecting some methanol, but I did not think it was that much when compared to the water component (% wise) of the mixture. Assuming your ECU is pulling timing when the meth is not running, that would result in less fuel being burned, and a more rich mixture being pulled out the exhaust... This is just thinking about theory.... I have very little experience with meth injection, personally...
John
Originally Posted by TRBOKEV,Aug 11 2008, 01:40 PM
This site has a TON of water/meth injection info...
http://forums.evolutionm.net/forumdisplay.php?f=173
http://forums.evolutionm.net/forumdisplay.php?f=173
Originally Posted by jwa4378,Aug 11 2008, 05:12 PM
S2Kart - How did your AFR go down with the meth working? I would think it would be the opposite (cooler air, plus water = more oxygen. More oxygen + same injector duty cycle + more timing = more lean mixture).
Originally Posted by jwa4378,Aug 11 2008, 05:12 PM
My main question would be if there are fail-safe measures to prevent detonation if the unit fails, are the adjustments (pulling timing, etc.) based on intake temp readings, or the output of the meth unit (unit sends signal to EMS, telling it that it is on and functioning)? If it does it based on whether the unit is "on" or "off" as opposed to threshold parameters on a result (intake temp) of the operation of the unit, it still may screw the engine if the controller unit still functions, but fails for some other reason (out of meth, leak, clogged sprayer, etc.).
I am not sure how the fail-safe's work. As long as the car is tuned to run without it, it should be fine, but then you are talking about not tuning for that 1.8% you could possibly gain by the cooler charge temp...
S2Kart - How did your AFR go down with the meth working? I would think it would be the opposite (cooler air, plus water = more oxygen. More oxygen + same injector duty cycle + more timing = more lean mixture). I know it is injecting some methanol, but I did not think it was that much when compared to the water component (% wise) of the mixture. Assuming your ECU is pulling timing when the meth is not running, that would result in less fuel being burned, and a more rich mixture being pulled out the exhaust... This is just thinking about theory.... I have very little experience with meth injection, personally...
John
I am not sure how the fail-safe's work. As long as the car is tuned to run without it, it should be fine, but then you are talking about not tuning for that 1.8% you could possibly gain by the cooler charge temp...
S2Kart - How did your AFR go down with the meth working? I would think it would be the opposite (cooler air, plus water = more oxygen. More oxygen + same injector duty cycle + more timing = more lean mixture). I know it is injecting some methanol, but I did not think it was that much when compared to the water component (% wise) of the mixture. Assuming your ECU is pulling timing when the meth is not running, that would result in less fuel being burned, and a more rich mixture being pulled out the exhaust... This is just thinking about theory.... I have very little experience with meth injection, personally...
John
mine is going to be setup thru a boost solenoid and will cut boost to 5psi if unit fails.
plus with the dds3 gauge I can monitor the flow accurately and quickly.
like s2kart said, if the unit doesn't fail your motor is actually safer than w/o it.
according to my tuner (Jon@hbspeed) you can run leaner on the map, say 12.5 but actually be at 11 because of the added timing you can pull with the meth.
anyways, i'm merely trying to relay to you guys what he said, so i could be wrong.
i'm not preaching that meth is the best thing ever, but i do agree it is a decent mod for the greddy kit. i'll post up results when my car is done.
Originally Posted by brilliant,Aug 11 2008, 07:28 PM
kits such as aquamist have great failsafes.
mine is going to be setup thru a boost solenoid and will cut boost to 5psi if unit fails.
plus with the dds3 gauge I can monitor the flow accurately and quickly.
like s2kart said, if the unit doesn't fail your motor is actually safer than w/o it.
according to my tuner (Jon@hbspeed) you can run leaner on the map, say 12.5 but actually be at 11 because of the added timing you can pull with the meth.
anyways, i'm merely trying to relay to you guys what he said, so i could be wrong.
i'm not preaching that meth is the best thing ever, but i do agree it is a decent mod for the greddy kit. i'll post up results when my car is done.
mine is going to be setup thru a boost solenoid and will cut boost to 5psi if unit fails.
plus with the dds3 gauge I can monitor the flow accurately and quickly.
like s2kart said, if the unit doesn't fail your motor is actually safer than w/o it.
according to my tuner (Jon@hbspeed) you can run leaner on the map, say 12.5 but actually be at 11 because of the added timing you can pull with the meth.
anyways, i'm merely trying to relay to you guys what he said, so i could be wrong.
i'm not preaching that meth is the best thing ever, but i do agree it is a decent mod for the greddy kit. i'll post up results when my car is done.
Just an FYI, the boost solenoid fail safe will only cut boost back to the spring wastegate psi, which in my car gets up to around 9PSI in VTEC... I will not be able to lower boost below that. Most of these failsafes were designed for people running higher boost levels (eg: an evo running 25 lbs of boost rather than a greddy kit that creeps to ten on the original wastegate spring)
I have yet to really see an effective fail safe besides the ones that pulls timing, but I have my doubts on those with the piggy back E manage Ultimate also.
kits such as aquamist have great failsafes.
mine is going to be setup thru a boost solenoid and will cut boost to 5psi if unit fails.
plus with the dds3 gauge I can monitor the flow accurately and quickly.
like s2kart said, if the unit doesn't fail your motor is actually safer than w/o it.
according to my tuner (Jon@hbspeed) you can run leaner on the map, say 12.5 but actually be at 11 because of the added timing you can pull with the meth.
anyways, i'm merely trying to relay to you guys what he said, so i could be wrong.
smile.gif
i'm not preaching that meth is the best thing ever, but i do agree it is a decent mod for the greddy kit. i'll post up results when my car is done.
mine is going to be setup thru a boost solenoid and will cut boost to 5psi if unit fails.
plus with the dds3 gauge I can monitor the flow accurately and quickly.
like s2kart said, if the unit doesn't fail your motor is actually safer than w/o it.
according to my tuner (Jon@hbspeed) you can run leaner on the map, say 12.5 but actually be at 11 because of the added timing you can pull with the meth.
anyways, i'm merely trying to relay to you guys what he said, so i could be wrong.
smile.gif
i'm not preaching that meth is the best thing ever, but i do agree it is a decent mod for the greddy kit. i'll post up results when my car is done.
WindchaserS2k - Do you know if the "flow rate" the unit tracks is a true "flow rate" and not just an injection rate? I am wondering if it can tell when its "out" of methanol mix (or if something clogs or something, but the unit is still on and "functioning")...
Thanks!
John


