Is it bad to press in the clutch and leave it..
Of course if you're on a motorcycle the recommended way to stop in traffic is on the left or right side of the lane to give you an escape route, in 1st, watching the rear view mirrors for anyone that might rear-end you.
Originally Posted by Saki GT,Jun 9 2006, 12:23 PM
only my foot on the clutch to keep the car from lurching.
The fear of leaving a car in gear with foot on clutch stems from the old days when we used to have clutch cables that could suddenly and without warning, SNAP. This isn't going to happen with a hydraulic clutch. Those old fears don't apply anymore.
Originally Posted by Ed_Grant,Jun 9 2006, 02:20 PM
Of course if you're on a motorcycle the recommended way to stop in traffic is on the left or right side of the lane to give you an escape route, in 1st, watching the rear view mirrors for anyone that might rear-end you.
When sitting in a line of traffic that is stopped, one should stop behind the guy in front so that you can see the rear tire touching the ground. This gives sufficient distance to either go around if needed or to pull up a bit more if needed. If you are the last car in the stopped line, it's always wise to watch behind for that next guy who comes up to you.
That's the "just in case" technique. If you just want to give your clutch foot a rest, well, that's also up to you.
Originally Posted by xviper,Jun 9 2006, 06:02 PM
I also have my foot on the brake.
The fear of leaving a car in gear with foot on clutch stems from the old days when we used to have clutch cables that could suddenly and without warning, SNAP. This isn't going to happen with a hydraulic clutch. Those old fears don't apply anymore.
The fear of leaving a car in gear with foot on clutch stems from the old days when we used to have clutch cables that could suddenly and without warning, SNAP. This isn't going to happen with a hydraulic clutch. Those old fears don't apply anymore.
X, I don't believe that a well maintained clutch cable is any more likely to snap than a well maintained hydrolic system is likely to burst a line. The operative words being "well maintained."
I let the clutch out when I'm stopped; It's a habit I developed early on, because holding in a really stiff clutch at a red light takes more muscle than I have available.
I guess I also feel safer with the car out of gear, just in case something does break and allow the clutch to engage (however unlikely that might be). I also keep my right foot *hard* on the brake, just in case someone wants to slam into my rear end.
As you've said, it shouldn't hurt anyting to hold the clutch in when stopped, but for long stops that sure is a waste of physical effort.
I let the clutch out when I'm stopped; It's a habit I developed early on, because holding in a really stiff clutch at a red light takes more muscle than I have available.
I guess I also feel safer with the car out of gear, just in case something does break and allow the clutch to engage (however unlikely that might be). I also keep my right foot *hard* on the brake, just in case someone wants to slam into my rear end.As you've said, it shouldn't hurt anyting to hold the clutch in when stopped, but for long stops that sure is a waste of physical effort.
Originally Posted by raymo19,Jun 9 2006, 03:08 PM
I take it that the "old school" idea of leaving the wheels straight while waiting to make a left turn is still in force though, eh?
Originally Posted by RED MX5,Jun 9 2006, 03:28 PM
I always use to put the bike in neutral and let the clutch out, but I always liked to keep my toe on the shifter, so I could get into gear and launch quickly if the situation demanded it. No standing at a stoplight with both feet on the ground.
Long waits when things are relatively known and safe, then yes, neutral is what we taught. However, when just about ready to proceed or when the situation is uncertain, we taught being in the "ready" position:
In 1st, clutch in, hand on throttle, right foot on brake, only left foot on ground to support.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
Uncle Fester
S2000 Talk
39
Nov 30, 2003 08:02 PM




