Are Carbon Doors Unsafe?
Originally Posted by Diez,May 11 2005, 09:04 AM
Good point as well! Doesn't the Challenge Stradale also have carbon doors?
Originally Posted by JSR_AP2,May 11 2005, 07:39 AM
Doors never take impact. The side impact bars or the door bars of a roll cage absorb the impact. The door skin is there for looks.
I agree with the above poster;
Mitsubishi even advertises that the fugly louvers on the doors of their outgoing Eclipse are there "not only for looks, but to increase the strength of the door in an impact".
Mitsubishi even advertises that the fugly louvers on the doors of their outgoing Eclipse are there "not only for looks, but to increase the strength of the door in an impact".
Originally Posted by Will,May 11 2005, 02:27 PM
"not only for looks, but to increase the strength of the door in an impact". 

Originally Posted by stewies2k,May 11 2005, 01:00 PM
If you're afraid of carbon door panels, you wouldn't be able to drive an enzo.
The Challenge Stradale has carbon interior door panels, but not the whole door.
The Amuse 350Z door is not hollow and may have the OEM side impact bars installed inside them. Again, door skins do not take impact! Yes, they absorb some amount of energy, but the amount of energy that's present when almost 2 tons hits you at xxMPH would flatten a door skin in an instant. Glue a straw at the tip end to a brick. Now, drop the brick with the straw's other tip end (the one not glued to the brick) facing the ground. Will the straw absorb some energy?...yes. Is that amount of energy negligible relative to the amount of energy present?...yes. The Mitsu commercial says the door design improves strength...likely in case of dent (more dent resistant), not in a crash.
Originally Posted by JSR_AP2,May 12 2005, 12:18 PM
The Amuse 350Z door is not hollow and may have the OEM side impact bars installed inside them.



