Y2K1S2K, just curious why don't you let your insurance replace it w/ a brand new one? Unless your comprehensive deductible is more than the rear bumper itself?

 

500 dollar deductible...plus i am 18 and my insurance will go wayyyy up...

 

That's a bummer...Good luck dude.

 

What he can do is take off the damaged bumper. Then take an unpainted bumper and the damaged one to a paint shop. The shop should be able to match up the paint from the damaged one. They're pretty easy to take on/off. If you're paranoid about leaving your car in the hands of a bodyshop its a good alternative.