S2KI Honda S2000 Forums

S2KI Honda S2000 Forums (https://www.s2ki.com/forums/)
-   S2000 Under The Hood (https://www.s2ki.com/forums/s2000-under-hood-22/)
-   -   Laskey Racing Engines Poor Performer (https://www.s2ki.com/forums/s2000-under-hood-22/laskey-racing-engines-poor-performer-1105569/)

JUSTINTHECOASTIE 11-24-2014 05:25 AM


Originally Posted by Billman250 (Post 23415168)
Anything over 8400 is really pushing it.

Lower VTEC to 5400, and you have a nice usable 3k rpm powerband just like the Ap1.

I've lowered vtec to 5.4k and still rev to 8.6-8.8k. At the time, it's mainly street driven and when I do go to the track I lower it to 8.5-8.6k

Slowcrash_101 11-24-2014 07:12 AM

Have you dyno'ed your car? I can essentially guarantee you're not making much power there. Obviously it's your car and you have every right to drive it as you wish, just saying revving an F22 that high isn't productive. :thumbup:

[media]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2JNnzqwTUMI[/media] probably been seen to death but it highlights why f22 has a lower rev limit. The technical jibber jabber starts at 2:35'ish

yamahaSHO 11-24-2014 07:32 AM


Originally Posted by Slowcrash_101 (Post 23415088)
It's possible but not advised, at 8400 rpm the f22 pistons have the same speed as f20 at 9,000. So you're pumping the same amount of air, because the bores haven't changed, only the stroke. In fact doing a little math at 9,000 rpm on the f22 crank and pistons, would be the equivalent of 9,670'ish rpm on an f20. The head stopped making power about 800 rpm ago.


:blink:

JUSTINTHECOASTIE 11-24-2014 07:42 AM


Originally Posted by Slowcrash_101 (Post 23416253)
Have you dyno'ed your car? I can essentially guarantee you're not making much power there. Obviously it's your car and you have every right to drive it as you wish, just saying revving an F22 that high isn't productive. :thumbup:

[media]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2JNnzqwTUMI[/media] probably been seen to death but it highlights why f22 has a lower rev limit. The technical jibber jabber starts at 2:35'ish

If this response was directed to me, yes I have dyno'd my car, check my thread, and many times after that. Reason why I like a higher rev limit is so that I'm higher in my powerband for the next 'up shift'. If you look at those dynos you are referring to, you should note that although power may not increase, power also doesn't dramatically drop of either.

Slowcrash_101 11-24-2014 08:56 AM


Originally Posted by yamahaSHO (Post 23416290)

Originally Posted by Slowcrash_101' timestamp='1416738566' post='23415088
It's possible but not advised, at 8400 rpm the f22 pistons have the same speed as f20 at 9,000. So you're pumping the same amount of air, because the bores haven't changed, only the stroke. In fact doing a little math at 9,000 rpm on the f22 crank and pistons, would be the equivalent of 9,670'ish rpm on an f20. The head stopped making power about 800 rpm ago.


:blink:

That's what the pistons do right? In conjunction with the valves, the pistons suck air, compress it, expand it(when mixed with a fuel and ignited), and pump it out. So for a given piston speed and travel, said piston will move a certain quantity of air provided the cylinder head ports and valves can provide said quantity. Is my understanding off base? If you exceed the capacity of the head and valves to supply air to the cylinders the car won't make more power, is this not correct?

So given the stroke is longer on the f22 than on an f20, the piston moves faster on the former, than the latter at a given rpm hence power drops off at a lower rpm on the f22 than on the f20 because the head and valves cannot supply enough air past a certain piston speed. Conversely more torque is made at lower rpms on an F22 vs F20 because of higher piston speed at lower rpms displacing more air in the F22 vs F20 because the flow potential of the head has not been exceeded.

If I'm wrong please correct me.

yamahaSHO 11-24-2014 09:03 AM


Originally Posted by Slowcrash_101 (Post 23416424)

Originally Posted by yamahaSHO' timestamp='1416846746' post='23416290
[quote name='Slowcrash_101' timestamp='1416738566' post='23415088']
It's possible but not advised, at 8400 rpm the f22 pistons have the same speed as f20 at 9,000. So you're pumping the same amount of air, because the bores haven't changed, only the stroke. In fact doing a little math at 9,000 rpm on the f22 crank and pistons, would be the equivalent of 9,670'ish rpm on an f20. The head stopped making power about 800 rpm ago.


:blink:

That's what the pistons do right? In conjunction with the valves, the pistons suck air, compress it, expand it(when mixed with a fuel and ignited), and pump it out. So for a given piston speed and travel, said piston will move a certain quantity of air provided the cylinder head ports and valves can provide said quantity. Is my understanding off base? If you exceed the capacity of the head and valves to supply air to the cylinders the car won't make more power, is this not correct?

So given the stroke is longer on the f22 than on an f20, the piston moves faster on the former, than the latter at a given rpm hence power drops off at a lower rpm on the f22 than on the f20 because the head and valves cannot supply enough air past a certain piston speed. Conversely more torque is made at lower rpms on an F22 vs F20 because of higher piston speed at lower rpms displacing more air in the F22 vs F20 because the flow potential of the head has not been exceeded.

If I'm wrong please correct me.
[/quote]

The stroke adds to the displacement.

The heads and valves are a completely different discussion.

Slowcrash_101 11-24-2014 09:15 AM


Originally Posted by yamahaSHO (Post 23416429)

Originally Posted by Slowcrash_101' timestamp='1416851786' post='23416424
[quote name='yamahaSHO' timestamp='1416846746' post='23416290']
[quote name='Slowcrash_101' timestamp='1416738566' post='23415088']
It's possible but not advised, at 8400 rpm the f22 pistons have the same speed as f20 at 9,000. So you're pumping the same amount of air, because the bores haven't changed, only the stroke. In fact doing a little math at 9,000 rpm on the f22 crank and pistons, would be the equivalent of 9,670'ish rpm on an f20. The head stopped making power about 800 rpm ago.


:blink:

That's what the pistons do right? In conjunction with the valves, the pistons suck air, compress it, expand it(when mixed with a fuel and ignited), and pump it out. So for a given piston speed and travel, said piston will move a certain quantity of air provided the cylinder head ports and valves can provide said quantity. Is my understanding off base? If you exceed the capacity of the head and valves to supply air to the cylinders the car won't make more power, is this not correct?

So given the stroke is longer on the f22 than on an f20, the piston moves faster on the former, than the latter at a given rpm hence power drops off at a lower rpm on the f22 than on the f20 because the head and valves cannot supply enough air past a certain piston speed. Conversely more torque is made at lower rpms on an F22 vs F20 because of higher piston speed at lower rpms displacing more air in the F22 vs F20 because the flow potential of the head has not been exceeded.

If I'm wrong please correct me.
[/quote]

The stroke adds to the displacement.

The heads and valves are a completely different discussion.
[/quote]

Longer stroke increases the volume of the cylinder this is true. It also increases piston speed for a given crank rpm, or is that wrong? As the length of a lever increases, it's motion ratio also increases. The combination of increased cylinder volume, and increased piston speed is what give you more pumping rates for a given rpm vs a shorter stroke. Or is this incorrect?

Slowcrash_101 11-24-2014 09:22 AM


Originally Posted by JUSTINTHECOASTIE (Post 23416300)

Originally Posted by Slowcrash_101' timestamp='1416845527' post='23416253
Have you dyno'ed your car? I can essentially guarantee you're not making much power there. Obviously it's your car and you have every right to drive it as you wish, just saying revving an F22 that high isn't productive. :thumbup:

[media]https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=2JNnzqwTUMI[/media] probably been seen to death but it highlights why f22 has a lower rev limit. The technical jibber jabber starts at 2:35'ish

If this response was directed to me, yes I have dyno'd my car, check my thread, and many times after that. Reason why I like a higher rev limit is so that I'm higher in my powerband for the next 'up shift'. If you look at those dynos you are referring to, you should note that although power may not increase, power also doesn't dramatically drop of either.

I stand corrected, and it makes sense, torque multiplication in a lower gear can essentially give you equal or higher acceleration compared to a taller gear even if the taller gear has a higher power output.

yamahaSHO 11-24-2014 10:04 AM


Originally Posted by Slowcrash_101 (Post 23416448)

Originally Posted by yamahaSHO' timestamp='1416852235' post='23416429
[quote name='Slowcrash_101' timestamp='1416851786' post='23416424']
[quote name='yamahaSHO' timestamp='1416846746' post='23416290']
[quote name='Slowcrash_101' timestamp='1416738566' post='23415088']
It's possible but not advised, at 8400 rpm the f22 pistons have the same speed as f20 at 9,000. So you're pumping the same amount of air, because the bores haven't changed, only the stroke. In fact doing a little math at 9,000 rpm on the f22 crank and pistons, would be the equivalent of 9,670'ish rpm on an f20. The head stopped making power about 800 rpm ago.


:blink:

That's what the pistons do right? In conjunction with the valves, the pistons suck air, compress it, expand it(when mixed with a fuel and ignited), and pump it out. So for a given piston speed and travel, said piston will move a certain quantity of air provided the cylinder head ports and valves can provide said quantity. Is my understanding off base? If you exceed the capacity of the head and valves to supply air to the cylinders the car won't make more power, is this not correct?

So given the stroke is longer on the f22 than on an f20, the piston moves faster on the former, than the latter at a given rpm hence power drops off at a lower rpm on the f22 than on the f20 because the head and valves cannot supply enough air past a certain piston speed. Conversely more torque is made at lower rpms on an F22 vs F20 because of higher piston speed at lower rpms displacing more air in the F22 vs F20 because the flow potential of the head has not been exceeded.

If I'm wrong please correct me.
[/quote]

The stroke adds to the displacement.

The heads and valves are a completely different discussion.
[/quote]

Longer stroke increases the volume of the cylinder this is true. It also increases piston speed for a given crank rpm, or is that wrong? As the length of a lever increases, it's motion ratio also increases. The combination of increased cylinder volume, and increased piston speed is what give you more pumping rates for a given rpm vs a shorter stroke. Or is this incorrect?
[/quote]

The longer stroke, by itself, is going to pump more air for a given revolution (and the intake tract will see this). Yes, you'll gain more speed for the same rotation as there is more distance to travel in that revolution, but the fact is you will still be filling more space. Whether or not intake path allows or makes use of it all is another subject.

For the most part, you're looking at piston speed from a safety standpoint... Wither it be more wear, overheating, overall vibration from running the motor higher, etc.


All times are GMT -8. The time now is 11:15 PM.


© 2024 MH Sub I, LLC dba Internet Brands