Another story thread.....
During that short state of "death", does the patients ever recollect any memory of dreams or anything?
If so, shouldn't the person experience some sort of afterlife or heaven (whatever your belief is). If not, doesn't that disprove religion? well, unless the argument for that is "he's not REALLY dead."
If so, shouldn't the person experience some sort of afterlife or heaven (whatever your belief is). If not, doesn't that disprove religion? well, unless the argument for that is "he's not REALLY dead."
Thread Starter
Former Moderator
Joined: Nov 2001
Posts: 59,195
Likes: 1
From: Ventura, California, USA
From my limited experience, NO.
It doesn't disprove religion in that religion is not scientific and so the 'state of being dead' does not coincide with death in a manner that God would recognize what is happening and not bring this person into the afterlife frey as per someone's specific religious beliefs.
It doesn't disprove religion in that religion is not scientific and so the 'state of being dead' does not coincide with death in a manner that God would recognize what is happening and not bring this person into the afterlife frey as per someone's specific religious beliefs.
Originally Posted by s2000raj,Sep 11 2008, 05:40 AM
From my limited experience, NO.
It doesn't disprove religion in that religion is not scientific and so the 'state of being dead' does not coincide with death in a manner that God would recognize what is happening and not bring this person into the afterlife frey as per someone's specific religious beliefs.
It doesn't disprove religion in that religion is not scientific and so the 'state of being dead' does not coincide with death in a manner that God would recognize what is happening and not bring this person into the afterlife frey as per someone's specific religious beliefs.
I spent 3 weeks discussing this in my philosophy class. Blahhhhhhhhh.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post




