I had something similar happen to me but on my Speed, some guy pulled into the spot next to me and scratched the entire quarter panel. I went through insurance though, my agent claimed it as vandalism, I just payed my deductible which was 260 I believe, the job itself was 680$. I worried it would mess up with my title or that my insurance rate would go up but neither of that happened...

 

I had a similar repair done on my 08 NFR. The guy who did it does small repairs for a living. He did a spot repair and you can't tell. He's in the Baltimore area. If you are anywhere near I'll give you his name.