Well if you were closer I'd offer to go for a ride with you and feel the issue you're talking about but, I'm in Victoria though so unless you're coming down here for something else it might not be worth it since all I'm gonna do is take it around the block to see what's going on.
The offer is there though.

Do you have to get a new one? No.
Should it be machined so that it's a fresh, perfectly smooth surface? Yes.

 

Yeah man for sure. I would love for u to check my car. I will let u know. I usually go there most of the weekend to visit family members. But let me know when ur available?

 

Hey Marc, if your taking the car to Chris at 5252 just ask him to evaluate your clutch..., He is a good guy and will do that for you before replacing it. He will tell you what is up. Mitch there is very good with S2000's as well.

 

Yeah man. I will do it if i have. Its just hard for me to travel over there not unless im going there for a visit.