Jason,
The TT is nice but it's really difficult seeing it set next to the S and deciding to take the Audi instead. The Audi just feels heavy and sluggish after driving the S.
Anyway, my reason for the X5 is that we have a 4 yr. old daughter and the X5 is bigger and much safer. Much more practical than the Audi.

 

5-series wagon would be safer and cheaper than the X5! (lower CG) But I respect your decision, and wish you luck with the new bimmer!

 

i actually test drove a tt roadster before i got the s2k
my wife liked the car...a lot slower than the s2k...but it had a lot more features.....s2k is best bang for buck though.....

 

It's a nice looking car, but it's the interior that I really like. Some people think it looks like a squished VW bug. In the end, I went with the s2k for performance. Reving to 9k rpms is just amazing.

 

VW New Beetle + Turbo + AWD = Audi 225 TT