Pneumatic vs electric wastegate actuator
#1
Pneumatic vs electric wastegate actuator
Hi.
Anyone try any electric actuator for wastegate of turbo?
Intead of a boost controller solenoid, using a electric motor to drive a flapper of the turbo with internal wastegate like borgwarner efr séries.
Any cons?
It should be more precise and faster than tradicional actuators and directly plugged to ecu
With a turbo speed sensor it should be perfect!
What do you think?
Anyone try any electric actuator for wastegate of turbo?
Intead of a boost controller solenoid, using a electric motor to drive a flapper of the turbo with internal wastegate like borgwarner efr séries.
Any cons?
It should be more precise and faster than tradicional actuators and directly plugged to ecu
With a turbo speed sensor it should be perfect!
What do you think?
#2
My Jeep Diesel has an electronic actuator on a VGT turbo (so no wastegate). It seems to work well, but it did fail... And it's SIGNIFICANTLY more money than a good 2-port actuator.
#3
The thing is that with a electronic actuator is more precise.
But if the reliability is not good maybe is better not to think about it
Maybe go for a 2 port actuator.
I have a 4 Port boost control solenoide
But if the reliability is not good maybe is better not to think about it
Maybe go for a 2 port actuator.
I have a 4 Port boost control solenoide
#5
Mahle says about theirs: "The electrical actuator can reach any desired wastegate position in a flash, regardless of the negative or positive system pressure. Its high clamping force ensures minimal leakage and consequently rapid boost pressure build-up. The result is very spontaneous responsiveness. Another advantage of the electrical actuator is the ability to open the wastegate completely."
#6
Don't some street cars come with an electric wastegate actuator. A quick google found one from a 2011 Kia for under $220.
Mahle says about theirs: "The electrical actuator can reach any desired wastegate position in a flash, regardless of the negative or positive system pressure. Its high clamping force ensures minimal leakage and consequently rapid boost pressure build-up. The result is very spontaneous responsiveness. Another advantage of the electrical actuator is the ability to open the wastegate completely."
Mahle says about theirs: "The electrical actuator can reach any desired wastegate position in a flash, regardless of the negative or positive system pressure. Its high clamping force ensures minimal leakage and consequently rapid boost pressure build-up. The result is very spontaneous responsiveness. Another advantage of the electrical actuator is the ability to open the wastegate completely."
#7
The why are aftermarket setups fooling around with 4-port boost controllers when things can be quickly and accurately controlled? Don't both use a similar PWM input?
Trending Topics
#8
That's a good point.
That's why I'm thinking of getting one of these instead a 4 Port solenoide and a 2 port actuator.
With a turbo speed sensor like mine it would be the ultimate boost Control
That's why I'm thinking of getting one of these instead a 4 Port solenoide and a 2 port actuator.
With a turbo speed sensor like mine it would be the ultimate boost Control
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
spdracerut
S2000 Racing and Competition
0
04-08-2015 05:52 PM
deathsled
S2000 Forced Induction
25
09-18-2007 11:44 AM