to tell you the truth, both are not bad. There are more of the si's than the s2, s2 a little bit faster, si more room, s2 is more exotic, si too common, both rank pretty well in quality, both have smooth slik look, if you have money both can be fast 1/4 mile, but s2 will take on on turns, etc, etc.

I understand where you are coming from now after making this list. for me and for you.

 

yea i have an 06 si and im in the same boat. im looking at an 04 and cant make up my mind at all its driving me nuts. i like my si and its my DD, im just worried about winters and stuff. the si is a great car, its fun handles good and looks hot with the HFP lip kit on it. i just dont know if i should buy the s2k i always wanted one but its not the most comfy car in the world. im also 5'9 235lbs so.....

 

im about 5'8'' 210 and its fine with me. I have a few guys who are bigger and its great for them as well.

 

The S is big enough. If you buy a civic you will continue looking for an S. you know, and I know it.

Man, I have 3 kids and I use my S for a DD. Why? Because my wife has a Pilot for bullshit needs, and no matter what I would have bought I would still be thinking about the S.

Life is too short. Go for it. You can always sell it if push comes to a shove. Even then, you had it for a while. Buy that Civic and you will never know

 

i have 2 cars. one is a acura 3.2CL which for a bigger car u still have to squeeze 4 people in it and it gets worse gas mileage then my s2k. im selling the CL cause of those reasons and getting a tsx. selling the s2k was never even a thought. i drove my s2k from ny to az and back and room was not an issue. either way insurance is gonna be pricey thats just part of owning a sporty honda. but id get what u think will fit better in u life and weather in ur area