Originally Posted by Car Analogy

Here we go again...

If you're gonna use your S like a sportbike, only on adventurous drives in good weather, when its warm out, and aren't concerned about things like noise or tire wear, and drive maybe 6k miles a year or less, then yes, extreme performance summer tires would be a better choice.

But if any of the above is not the case, MPSS are a great tire for the S. The only possible drawback is the sidewalls are not as stiff as the original tires, and this gives up a degree of responsiveness that some find enough of a drawback to make extreme performance tires worth it.

It all comes down to what compromises you are willing to accept.

Sent from my SM-G920P using IB AutoGroup