Car Talk - Non S2000 General Motoring and Non S2000 Car Talk

What next...

Thread Tools
 
Old Jul 21, 2011 | 12:24 AM
  #31  
gbduo's Avatar
Registered User
 
Joined: Apr 2010
Posts: 3,848
Likes: 0
From: Southampton/Reading
Default

Originally Posted by Mistress Quickly
Originally Posted by gbduo' timestamp='1311153113' post='20796239
Nah, XKR is a great car, I would love one of them! I am 24 and have a XJ8 for motorway runs and to catch up on V8 goodness. The running costs are horrendous though, £1200 for a set of tyres...
Think this is one?



A dear old friend, a gentleman of a certain age, turned up in it. He used to change his clothes three times a day when we went on growers' trips and hold hands with Mr Q when crossing the road. It is a syrup friendly convertible - allegedly. Somehow not the thing for an ex S2000 owner I think?
Haha!

I prefer the older one, the one that looked more like the E-Type it was based on before it had to conform with new EU Regs, this one:-



But yes, it is no S, but not many cars are as pointed and give a decent drivers feel like a S as most people don't want that. I would test drive one, but yeh, I agree it is tricky to find a replacement for the S if you want something that will drive very similar with more power.

I am getting a Westfield. Although admittedly, I am not selling the S either so the Westfield will compliment the S.
Reply
Old Jul 21, 2011 | 07:17 AM
  #32  
mikey k's Avatar
20 Year Member
 
Joined: Nov 2003
Posts: 25,566
Likes: 2
From: Heart of England
Default

For less than the cost of a 5.0 XKR you could have an early 4.3 Vantage Roadster
Reply
Old Jul 21, 2011 | 07:53 AM
  #33  
Nick Graves's Avatar
 
Joined: Mar 2001
Posts: 31,181
Likes: 58
From: Hertford
Default

Originally Posted by gbduo
Originally Posted by Mistress Quickly' timestamp='1311187444' post='20797943
[quote name='gbduo' timestamp='1311153113' post='20796239']
Nah, XKR is a great car, I would love one of them! I am 24 and have a XJ8 for motorway runs and to catch up on V8 goodness. The running costs are horrendous though, £1200 for a set of tyres...
Think this is one?



A dear old friend, a gentleman of a certain age, turned up in it. He used to change his clothes three times a day when we went on growers' trips and hold hands with Mr Q when crossing the road. It is a syrup friendly convertible - allegedly. Somehow not the thing for an ex S2000 owner I think?
Haha!

I prefer the older one, the one that looked more like the E-Type it was based on before it had to conform with new EU Regs, this one:-



But yes, it is no S, but not many cars are as pointed and give a decent drivers feel like a S as most people don't want that. I would test drive one, but yeh, I agree it is tricky to find a replacement for the S if you want something that will drive very similar with more power.

I am getting a Westfield. Although admittedly, I am not selling the S either so the Westfield will compliment the S.

[/quote]

Why on earth would you prefer an overbodied 1970s XJ-S/XJ40 mashup to a lightweight, purpose-built aluminium-bodied GT roadster?

Go drive yer Westie; it'll learn yer about lightweight & transient reponsiveness!
Reply
Old Jul 21, 2011 | 08:30 AM
  #34  
Shipley's Avatar
Registered User
 
Joined: Mar 2002
Posts: 5,184
Likes: 0
From: South
Default

[/quote] its about how you "feel" driving it in the real world. [/quote]

Which is why I ended up getting a 911 Carrera 2. In the real world its exciting at any speed, feels solid, quick and special and I've wanted one for years. 22mpg overall and does 36mpg on a pootle with Mrs Shipley when we go to the coast for lunch.

Not that I give a toss about mpg but I'm surprised how reasonable it is to own.

Dealers are high quality too.
Reply
Old Jul 21, 2011 | 08:56 AM
  #35  
gbduo's Avatar
Registered User
 
Joined: Apr 2010
Posts: 3,848
Likes: 0
From: Southampton/Reading
Default

Originally Posted by Nick Graves
Originally Posted by gbduo' timestamp='1311236647' post='20800117
[quote name='Mistress Quickly' timestamp='1311187444' post='20797943']
[quote name='gbduo' timestamp='1311153113' post='20796239']
Nah, XKR is a great car, I would love one of them! I am 24 and have a XJ8 for motorway runs and to catch up on V8 goodness. The running costs are horrendous though, £1200 for a set of tyres...
Think this is one?



A dear old friend, a gentleman of a certain age, turned up in it. He used to change his clothes three times a day when we went on growers' trips and hold hands with Mr Q when crossing the road. It is a syrup friendly convertible - allegedly. Somehow not the thing for an ex S2000 owner I think?
Haha!

I prefer the older one, the one that looked more like the E-Type it was based on before it had to conform with new EU Regs, this one:-



But yes, it is no S, but not many cars are as pointed and give a decent drivers feel like a S as most people don't want that. I would test drive one, but yeh, I agree it is tricky to find a replacement for the S if you want something that will drive very similar with more power.

I am getting a Westfield. Although admittedly, I am not selling the S either so the Westfield will compliment the S.

[/quote]

Why on earth would you prefer an overbodied 1970s XJ-S/XJ40 mashup to a lightweight, purpose-built aluminium-bodied GT roadster?

Go drive yer Westie; it'll learn yer about lightweight & transient reponsiveness!
[/quote]

I think they look better! More purposeful and less obese than the new ones.

But yeh, I currently have my eye on a Westie with a XE 2ltr red top on Jenveys, should do the job. What is transient responsiveness?
Reply
Old Jul 21, 2011 | 10:13 AM
  #36  
m1bjr's Avatar
15 Year Member
Liked
Loved
 
Joined: Oct 2006
Posts: 11,445
Likes: 7
From: Plymouth
Default

Originally Posted by Nick Graves
Originally Posted by gbduo' timestamp='1311236647' post='20800117
[quote name='Mistress Quickly' timestamp='1311187444' post='20797943']
[quote name='gbduo' timestamp='1311153113' post='20796239']
Nah, XKR is a great car, I would love one of them! I am 24 and have a XJ8 for motorway runs and to catch up on V8 goodness. The running costs are horrendous though, £1200 for a set of tyres...
Think this is one?



A dear old friend, a gentleman of a certain age, turned up in it. He used to change his clothes three times a day when we went on growers' trips and hold hands with Mr Q when crossing the road. It is a syrup friendly convertible - allegedly. Somehow not the thing for an ex S2000 owner I think?
Haha!

I prefer the older one, the one that looked more like the E-Type it was based on before it had to conform with new EU Regs, this one:-



But yes, it is no S, but not many cars are as pointed and give a decent drivers feel like a S as most people don't want that. I would test drive one, but yeh, I agree it is tricky to find a replacement for the S if you want something that will drive very similar with more power.

I am getting a Westfield. Although admittedly, I am not selling the S either so the Westfield will compliment the S.

[/quote]

Why on earth would you prefer an overbodied 1970s XJ-S/XJ40 mashup to a lightweight, purpose-built aluminium-bodied GT roadster?

Go drive yer Westie; it'll learn yer about lightweight & transient reponsiveness!
[/quote]


They call 'em tran-sexual down 'ere buy.

I take it we are on the same page - "flicking between one side and the other" ?

Reply
Old Jul 21, 2011 | 11:37 AM
  #37  
Nick Graves's Avatar
 
Joined: Mar 2001
Posts: 31,181
Likes: 58
From: Hertford
Default

Originally Posted by gbduo
Originally Posted by Nick Graves' timestamp='1311263625' post='20801213
[quote name='gbduo' timestamp='1311236647' post='20800117']
[quote name='Mistress Quickly' timestamp='1311187444' post='20797943']
[quote name='gbduo' timestamp='1311153113' post='20796239']
Nah, XKR is a great car, I would love one of them! I am 24 and have a XJ8 for motorway runs and to catch up on V8 goodness. The running costs are horrendous though, £1200 for a set of tyres...
Think this is one?



A dear old friend, a gentleman of a certain age, turned up in it. He used to change his clothes three times a day when we went on growers' trips and hold hands with Mr Q when crossing the road. It is a syrup friendly convertible - allegedly. Somehow not the thing for an ex S2000 owner I think?
Haha!

I prefer the older one, the one that looked more like the E-Type it was based on before it had to conform with new EU Regs, this one:-



But yes, it is no S, but not many cars are as pointed and give a decent drivers feel like a S as most people don't want that. I would test drive one, but yeh, I agree it is tricky to find a replacement for the S if you want something that will drive very similar with more power.

I am getting a Westfield. Although admittedly, I am not selling the S either so the Westfield will compliment the S.

[/quote]

Why on earth would you prefer an overbodied 1970s XJ-S/XJ40 mashup to a lightweight, purpose-built aluminium-bodied GT roadster?

Go drive yer Westie; it'll learn yer about lightweight & transient reponsiveness!
[/quote]

I think they look better! More purposeful and less obese than the new ones.

But yeh, I currently have my eye on a Westie with a XE 2ltr red top on Jenveys, should do the job. What is transient responsiveness?
[/quote]

Flickability.
Reply
Old Jul 21, 2011 | 11:40 AM
  #38  
Nick Graves's Avatar
 
Joined: Mar 2001
Posts: 31,181
Likes: 58
From: Hertford
Default

Originally Posted by m1bjr
Originally Posted by Nick Graves' timestamp='1311263625' post='20801213
[quote name='gbduo' timestamp='1311236647' post='20800117']
[quote name='Mistress Quickly' timestamp='1311187444' post='20797943']
[quote name='gbduo' timestamp='1311153113' post='20796239']
Nah, XKR is a great car, I would love one of them! I am 24 and have a XJ8 for motorway runs and to catch up on V8 goodness. The running costs are horrendous though, £1200 for a set of tyres...
Think this is one?



A dear old friend, a gentleman of a certain age, turned up in it. He used to change his clothes three times a day when we went on growers' trips and hold hands with Mr Q when crossing the road. It is a syrup friendly convertible - allegedly. Somehow not the thing for an ex S2000 owner I think?
Haha!

I prefer the older one, the one that looked more like the E-Type it was based on before it had to conform with new EU Regs, this one:-



But yes, it is no S, but not many cars are as pointed and give a decent drivers feel like a S as most people don't want that. I would test drive one, but yeh, I agree it is tricky to find a replacement for the S if you want something that will drive very similar with more power.

I am getting a Westfield. Although admittedly, I am not selling the S either so the Westfield will compliment the S.

[/quote]

Why on earth would you prefer an overbodied 1970s XJ-S/XJ40 mashup to a lightweight, purpose-built aluminium-bodied GT roadster?

Go drive yer Westie; it'll learn yer about lightweight & transient reponsiveness!
[/quote]


They call 'em tran-sexual down 'ere buy.

I take it we are on the same page - "flicking between one side and the other" ?


[/quote]

As roight, buy.

Is Transexual a commercial version of Metrosexual?
Reply
Old Jul 21, 2011 | 03:24 PM
  #39  
Ultra_Nexus's Avatar
Registered User
 
Joined: May 2006
Posts: 12,330
Likes: 0
From: Frustration
Default

On my recent track day I drove 3 cars back to back in quick succession.

My Westfield, A Golf Mk5 with 310bhp and an Evo IV RS with uprated suspension.

Want to know the difference? Drive your S2000 and then get into a Transit van (although it has to be said that a transit van is suprisingly good in terms of feel). High seating position, muted response, a bit wallowy, steering wheel not out of place in 'Convoy'?

A lot of people move on from the S2000 and hark on about their new car's brilliance. Don't get me wrong, I love my Westfield as it's completely barmy. Crap at most things, brilliant at one

However, it also made me realise just how good the S2000 is as an all rounder. It's such a nice car to drive

The only reason you'd want to get rid is because the insurance costs are quite ludicrous, as is the road tax (on newer models).

If I had to suggest something, i'd say Porsche Boxster S (987). Lacks the S2000's frenetic character, but is a genuinely nice to drive car.
Reply
Old Jul 21, 2011 | 10:51 PM
  #40  
eSeM's Avatar
20 Year Member
 
Joined: Dec 2001
Posts: 39,548
Likes: 11
From: City Of London / Knebworth
Default

Originally Posted by mikey k
For less than the cost of a 5.0 XKR you could have an early 4.3 Vantage Roadster, RAC Membership and shares in Avis Car Rental.
Corrected!

Reply



All times are GMT -8. The time now is 08:51 PM.