After 4 years of ownership I realized that the metal tag attached to the dash ends in 00058 and the sticker on the door jam ends in 000580. The stickers on the hood, fenders, etc. end in 00580. Do I have car 58 or 580?

 

I believe that VINs are 17 alphanumeric characters.

 

The last 6 digits are #'s. Looks like your'e missing one on the dash tag (either 000058 or 000580)
I would double check, but I'm guessing it's 580.