Well, it's not a car, but I recently replaced my S with a 04 zx6rr.

 

another S2k!

 

A C5-z06 with 1/3rd the miles.

 

Boxster Spyder or Scion FRS.

The Boxster Spyder is basically a Boxster with the RS treatment, probably the closest thing to our S2K at a reasonable price.

The Scion FRS is the most exciting and resonably priced car to come out of the Honda/Toyota with almost guaranteed reliability and easy maintenance.
One thing I missed about driving a non-sports car is that you can actually lean the seat back for a quick nap to recharge the batteries. With my S2K, I just drive faster to get more adrenaline pumping.

 

if i could afford these, i would get the new z4 since it looks nicer now or the new hatchback sti's. they are growing on me!

 

FD RX-7. With a 517rwhp LS2/L92. Very soon...

 

If i wanted something similar -
Z4M coupe (e86)
Elise SC or Exige 240

If I decided to go turbo
BMW 135i or the new M1 coupe if I could afford it

If I wanted to find a comfortable daily,

C63 AMG

 

A coffin?

I don't intend to "replace" the S or my CRX. However, I would compliment it with a SC Acura TL (previous gen) if I wanted a reasonable family car, or a Evo X if I wanted an unreasonable one, or a TT C6 Z06 for drag purposes.

 

I'd definitely go for a 1997 NSX in Kaiser Silver. It's destined to be a classic and it'll hold it value, much like my low mileage AP2!

 

nice! ^^ my 05 NFR has 8,270 miles! I think we might be the lowest mileaged 05 nfrs on S2ki!