FIA Decision
Originally Posted by matrix,Sep 26 2007, 08:45 AM
Beyond me how a "whistleblower" can go to a competitor and not the authorities with information.
http://www.grandprix.com/ns/ns19721.html
Anyone else feels that Ferrari should be penalized too?
Not like Mclaren sent someone into Ferrari to steal info.
It was given by someone on the inside. Mclaren only
wrong doing is not reporting to the FIA.
Ferrari should have better security then to let employees
take HIGHLY secret info like technical data from the
facility.
I still can't help thinking that Ferrari planned this as a
plan B if they did not perform well enough to be
#1.
Not like Mclaren sent someone into Ferrari to steal info.
It was given by someone on the inside. Mclaren only
wrong doing is not reporting to the FIA.
Ferrari should have better security then to let employees
take HIGHLY secret info like technical data from the
facility.
I still can't help thinking that Ferrari planned this as a
plan B if they did not perform well enough to be
#1.
According to the man himself he did go to the FIA about the moving floor Ferrari.
http://www.grandprix.com/ns/ns19721.html
http://www.grandprix.com/ns/ns19721.html

NS has zero credibility left.
Originally Posted by S2000spoon,Oct 4 2007, 11:32 AM
I still can't help thinking that Ferrari planned this as a
plan B if they did not perform well enough to be
#1.
plan B if they did not perform well enough to be
#1.
Sure...Ferrari controls everything in the world.....Ferrari told MC wife to go to a print shop and copy the dossier...yay, I think that happened.
Originally Posted by matrix,Oct 4 2007, 11:41 AM
Sure...Ferrari controls everything in the world.....Ferrari told MC wife to go to a print shop and copy the dossier...yay, I think that happened.
Is it so hard to believe any manufacturer would do what
they can?
With everything thing being top secret with the teams,
how in the world you let an employee take hundreds of
pages technical data out of the facility?
Sorry, but it smells a little fishy.
Could have been a set-up, why not? Big corporations use "competitive intelligence" to outdo their rivals, from "imbedding" one of their employees inside to stealing/spying, etc. It's a possibility.
I'm a Ferrari fan, but I just don't understand how the FIA could hand down such a HUGE fine based on "suspicion." What kind of concrete evidence do they have besides hearsay?
I'm a Ferrari fan, but I just don't understand how the FIA could hand down such a HUGE fine based on "suspicion." What kind of concrete evidence do they have besides hearsay?
Originally Posted by matrix,Oct 4 2007, 11:41 AM
Sure...Ferrari controls everything in the world.....Ferrari told MC wife to go to a print shop and copy the dossier...yay, I think that happened.
The clear favoritism the FIA shows Ferrari kind makes it hard in my mind at least to just brush off what NS is saying as BS. But I do agree with you that NS isn't the benevolent savior to F1 that he is trying to paint himself as. He's clearly a man that has his own best interests in mind.
Originally Posted by f1_fanz,Oct 4 2007, 11:55 AM
Could have been a set-up, why not? Big corporations use "competitive intelligence" to outdo their rivals, from "imbedding" one of their employees inside to stealing/spying, etc. It's a possibility.
I'm a Ferrari fan, but I just don't understand how the FIA could hand down such a HUGE fine based on "suspicion." What kind of concrete evidence do they have besides hearsay?
I'm a Ferrari fan, but I just don't understand how the FIA could hand down such a HUGE fine based on "suspicion." What kind of concrete evidence do they have besides hearsay?
But maybe you're right...NS was INSIDE of Ferrari, maybe McLaren did set this all up and had it blow up in their face...
Good point!
Originally Posted by S2000spoon,Oct 4 2007, 11:49 AM
F1 is a cut throat sport with so much money involved.
Is it so hard to believe any manufacturer would do what
they can?
With everything thing being top secret with the teams,
how in the world you let an employee take hundreds of
pages technical data out of the facility?
Sorry, but it smells a little fishy.
Is it so hard to believe any manufacturer would do what
they can?
With everything thing being top secret with the teams,
how in the world you let an employee take hundreds of
pages technical data out of the facility?
Sorry, but it smells a little fishy.
Originally Posted by Cypher09,Oct 4 2007, 12:19 PM
At the end of the day it's NS that instigated the whole issue as an employee of Ferrari and per the FIA the teams are responsible for the actions of their employees are they not? How can you let an employee out of the office with a printed copy of the "Entire" technical dossier of your car? But Ferrari managed to escape with out penalty yet again.
The clear favoritism the FIA shows Ferrari kind makes it hard in my mind at least to just brush off what NS is saying as BS. But I do agree with you that NS isn't the benevolent savior to F1 that he is trying to paint himself as. He's clearly a man that has his own best interests in mind.
The clear favoritism the FIA shows Ferrari kind makes it hard in my mind at least to just brush off what NS is saying as BS. But I do agree with you that NS isn't the benevolent savior to F1 that he is trying to paint himself as. He's clearly a man that has his own best interests in mind.
Why haven't McLaren fired MC?
FIA favor Ferrari??? I have no idea how you can even say that after all we have seen this year....



